For many retirees, living solely on the dividends generated by their portfolio feels like a safe and stable approach to retirement income. This strategy can provide a sense of security by avoiding the need to sell assets, allowing retirees to hold onto their principal. However, while it may seem like an ideal strategy, living on dividends alone may have hidden costs and risks.
In this article, we’ll explore the drawbacks of a “dividend-only” approach to retirement income and present some alternative strategies to consider for a more balanced and secure retirement.
Relying solely on dividends may seem appealing, but there are several risks associated with this strategy:
Understanding these risks can help you make more informed decisions about your retirement income strategy.
Aiming to live off dividends often leads investors to favor high-dividend-paying investments. The issue? High-dividend stocks are often value-oriented, potentially excluding growth investments, which limits diversification.
Example Scenario
Let’s say you’re invested solely in high-dividend stocks or ETFs. If one of these companies hits financial difficulties and cuts its dividend—a common scenario during economic downturns—you could face a substantial drop in income. Additionally, high-dividend yields can sometimes signal financial distress, meaning the company may be facing financial challenges that could impact its future performance.
In a well-diversified portfolio, a balance of growth and value investments (including bonds) can reduce risk. Growth investments, while not typically dividend-heavy, provide long-term appreciation that balances the income generated by dividend-paying stocks.
Potential Risks of High-Dividend Strategies:
Depending on the type of dividend (qualified or non-qualified), dividends can create tax liabilities that may not be as efficient as capital gains. Qualified dividends are taxed at a lower, long-term capital gains rate, whereas non-qualified dividends are taxed as ordinary income, which can be significantly higher.
Consider the Timing of Dividend Payments
Dividend income also arrives on a predetermined schedule, often quarterly, which doesn’t allow you to control the timing of taxable events. When you sell assets at a capital gain, you have more control over when the taxable event occurs, enabling you to optimize your tax situation. For those still saving for retirement, high-dividend stocks can be especially inefficient since you may face annual taxes on dividends, slowing portfolio growth.
Strategies for Tax Efficiency:
Aiming to live off dividends alone can lead to underspending, especially in the early years of retirement. Let’s look at a case study to illustrate this risk:
Case Study: Jamie’s Retirement Strategy
Jamie is a 59-year-old retiree with $1 million in retirement savings. Her goal is to live off the 3% dividend yield from her portfolio, providing her $30,000 annually without touching the principal. While this may seem prudent, Jamie’s careful approach could lead her to underspend, potentially resulting in regret later in life.
In Jamie’s case, a retirement analysis showed she had a 100% probability of success in her current approach, meaning she was unlikely to run out of money. However, the analysis also revealed that she could end her life with twice the amount she started with—$2 million. This excess may indicate missed opportunities for travel, hobbies, and experiences in her more active retirement years.
Key Takeaways:
Rather than focusing solely on dividends, here are some alternative strategies that can offer a more balanced approach to retirement income.
To avoid the risks associated with high-dividend bias, maintain a diversified portfolio that balances growth and income. Here are some steps to consider:
For those still accumulating wealth or transitioning into retirement, strategically placing investments in different types of accounts can improve tax efficiency.
A total return strategy can provide flexibility by allowing you to sell assets as needed rather than relying solely on dividends. This strategy lets you generate income from both capital gains and dividends, which can offer better control over tax liabilities.
Retirement income guardrails set flexible spending rules, allowing you to adjust income up or down based on portfolio performance. Guardrails enable retirees to increase their income in good years and cut back during economic downturns, helping to avoid the pitfalls of overspending or underspending.
While living solely on dividends can be appealing, it has limitations that may impact your long-term financial health. From potential tax inefficiencies to underspending risks and lack of diversification, the drawbacks of a dividend-only strategy can hinder a fulfilling retirement.
A balanced approach—one that includes a diversified portfolio, tax-efficient allocation, and flexible spending guardrails—can provide a more robust and adaptable retirement income strategy. This approach allows you to enjoy a comfortable retirement without the financial stress of outliving your assets.
If you’re interested in learning more about retirement income strategies, reach out to us at Spark Wealth Advisors for personalized guidance. And for more insights on retirement planning, subscribe to our channel.
.png)
